Well, they certainly nailed it.
From Pitchfork’s 4.7 review of the latest Weezer album:
Sadly, the once burned-out Weezer continue to fade away: Those first two records capture their decade in 75 minutes of near-perfect power-pop: straight-faced irony, eccentric sincerity, meta references, and bipolar guitar distortion from ordinary-looking outcasts who became stars and then complained about it. Punk that’s too catchy to offend. Pop that’s too smart to cop to itself. And, uh, emo.